Why We Have Become Dumb
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) recently published a study about the literacy, numeracy, and problem solving aptitude of its' 23 respective member states. After analyzing the data, the findings indicated the US rates near the bottom in each category. The US scored 16th in literacy, 21st in numeracy, and 14th in problem solving abilities. Perhaps more importantly, these findings were about the nations' adult population, which entails that the US workforce has lower-levels of literacy, numeracy, and problem solving acumen than its counterparts in other member nations. As an educator, I had two thoughts: one, I was horrified at the findings; two, I was not surprised at the results. The recent political crisis and the lackadaisical economic recovery might be evidence to a poorly education population.
Over the past couple of days since reviewing the OECD report, I have been racking my brain to understand why the US scored so poorly. This is certainly not a nation of underachievers, as it has done rather well thus far, but why is the country failing in educating its citizenry while other nations seem to be thriving - or at least outpacing the US.
Several thoughts come to mind regarding this phenomenon. Perhaps it is a lack of respect toward teachers in general. Teachers receive little recompense for their efforts, and given the free market paradigm this nations rests on, this might indicated a lack of concern for the education system. There is also the view that education is a right rather than a privilege. A type of crisis of the commons may be emerging in which the perception of education is as a public good, and as such, does not receive the support or close attention it deserves. The reason could be apathetic students (and adults) who care more about the social aspects of education than the learning process, as undereducated adults may not emphasize the importance of learning to their progeny. In addition, the causation could stem from teachers, who are more concerned with test score measurements (though such measures are imposed upon them) as opposed to whether students are learning.
I believe it might be an unholy alchemy of all the above-mentioned reasons as well as many more not included in this list of failure. Whatever the reasons, it is vital for us in the education profession to take stock of these results and begin to strategize and reformulate the educational process in this country. I recently heard a rather clever analogy alluding to the government shutdown, "American may still be a shining city on a hill, but the lights have gone off, and the world no longer has a guidepost." Although I cannot begin to understand the nuances and behind the sense shenanigans that contributed to the government shutdown, I do know that we must strive as faculty to help our students engage fully in the learning process and not just memorizing briefly the course concepts.
Thanks,
Eric Nordin
Reference the report:
Page Options
3 Comments
Sounds like the essence of Kubrick's dark prophecy.
Of course, it does not help that in Western Culture the Bible is no longer welcome in the "common core" of study at the University. Consequently, there has been a dumbing down and narrowing of our understanding. Recovery of the Bible as a source of wisdom and authority may help us answer tough questions such as, "What is reality?" "How should I treat fellow humans?" An outgrowth of understanding the Bible's unique message is that we become more human and capable of mastering the liberal arts.
Zondervan has a book out that deals with this subject titled, "The Bible and the University" http://www.amazon.com/Bible-University-Scripture-Hermeneutics-Series/dp/0310234182
Hello Robert:
I think you bring up a great point about how the lack of a foundational understanding regarding human ethics as well as the genius of critical thought have create a relativistic sense of knowledge, which has proven to be harmful toward our knowledge acquisition. In addition, thanks for posting a great resource.
Eric